How to Pick the Best Steaks at the Grocery Store — cooking, recipes, bon apetit

Close-up of a grocery butcher counter with various steak cuts (ribeye, filet, sirloin, flank) showing marbling and thickness; a shopper's gloved hand selects a steak beside salt, pepper, a knife and rosemary.

Steak shopping can feel like a small celebration and a careful decision all at once. For anyone who loves cooking, recipes, bon apetit, choosing the right cut makes a night memorable. This friendly guide breaks choices down into four simple factors and then matches popular cuts to occasions so every steak purchase feels smart and satisfying.

Key takeaways

  • Tenderness depends on where the cut comes from on the animal.
  • Flavor largely tracks with fat and marbling.
  • Size matters: thicker steaks are easier to cook well and develop a better crust.
  • Price categories help decide what to splurge on and what to save on.

Four things to check when buying steak

1. Tenderness

Tenderness is a function of movement. Muscles that do less work, like the tenderloin, are naturally tender. Muscles that get daily exercise, like skirt or flank, have more chew. Pick the texture you want for your meal rather than assuming tender always equals better.

2. Flavor

Flavor is mostly about fat. More intramuscular fat, also called marbling, equals richer flavor and juicier bites. Prime and choice grades show pleasant marbling. Avoid select when flavor is the priority — it is very lean and often underwhelming.

Close-up of two raw steaks on a white plate showing visible marbling and fat

3. Size

Thicker steaks are forgiving. A one-inch-plus thick steak stays on the heat longer, giving time to form a deep crust without overcooking the center. A 12 or 16 ounce steak sliced and shared makes a wonderful dinner for two.

4. Price

Steak prices have climbed, so group cuts into three buckets to decide when to splurge and when to save.

Best steaks by occasion

Luxe (splurge)

Strip steak, rib eye, and tenderloin sit in the luxe category. The strip offers a beefy flavor with a pleasant chew. The rib eye is juicier and more marbled, perfect for the grill. Tenderloin is the most tender but the leanest; it shines with butter, sauce, or a pepper crust.

Hand pointing to a selection of raw steaks (tenderloin medallion, strip and ribeye) on a cutting board

Party steaks

T-bone and porterhouse are effectively two steaks in one: tenderloin on one side and strip on the other. Because the tenderloin cooks faster, position it away from the highest heat when grilling to keep both sides even. These make a great centerpiece for group meals.

two T‑bone porterhouse steaks on a wooden cutting board showing bone and marbling

Moderately priced (everyday)

Flank, sirloin flap, and skirt steaks are flavorful, versatile, and often more budget-friendly. Flank is large with a clear grain and should not be cooked past medium; slice thin against the grain. Sirloin flap is excellent for steak tips or stir fries — buy whole and cut at home. Skirt is beefy and slightly fattier than flank, and its narrow width is perfect for tortillas and fajitas.

Close-up of flank and skirt steaks highlighting pronounced grain and marbling

Shopping and cooking tips

  • Buy thicker steaks for easier timing and a better crust.
  • Match cut to cooking method: grill big party steaks, pan-sear thicker single steaks, and quickly cook or marinate thinner cuts for tacos or stir fries.
  • Slice against the grain for flank, skirt, and other long-grained cuts to maximize tenderness.
  • Consider grade: prime and choice will reward with more flavor due to marbling.

For cooks who love cooking, recipes, bon apetit, these simple rules make steak shopping joyful and reliable. Choosing the right cut for the occasion means less guesswork and more delicious dinners.

Final tips for happy steak nights

Keep a few favorites on rotation: a rib eye for weekend grilling, a strip for a special dinner, and skirt or flank for weeknight meals. When in doubt, pick a thicker cut, mind the grain, and celebrate the flavors. Sharing a well-chosen steak is a small ritual that says care and taste. Enjoy the process and the meal itself — cooking, recipes, bon apetit is what brings it all together.

One last friendly note: for anyone who loves cooking, recipes, bon apetit, a bit of planning goes a long way. Happy cooking!

This article was created from the video How to Pick the Best Steaks at the Grocery Store | America's Test Kitchen with the help of AI.

How to Pick the Best Steaks at the Grocery Store — cooking, recipes, bon apetit. There are any How to Pick the Best Steaks at the Grocery Store — cooking, recipes, bon apetit in here.